Journal of Management Information and Decision Sciences (Print ISSN: 1524-7252; Online ISSN: 1532-5806)

Research Article: 2023 Vol: 26 Issue: 6S

G2G Adoption in Egypt

Mohamed Mohamed AbdElaziz Youssef, AIN Shams University

Citation Information: AbdElaziz Youssef, M.M. (2023). G2G adoption in Egypt. Journal of Management Information and Decision Sciences, 26 (S6),1-12.

Abstract

Data is quite possibly of the most significant asset in government. Government supervisors are finding in any case, that data expected to design, decide, and act is much of the time held external their own associations, kept up with in divergent arrangements, and utilized for broadly various purposes. Endeavors to unite this information across limits have given new comprehension into exactly how troublesome cross-limit data sharing is. Tracking down ways of uniting data and coordinate it for use in tackling squeezing public issues is quick turning into a focal point of consideration for computerized government professionals and scientists the same.

Keywords

Business and Management.

Introduction

Problem Definition

Data is quite possibly of the most significant asset in government. Government supervisors are finding in any case, that data expected to design, decide, and act is much of the time held external their own associations, kept up with in divergent arrangements, and utilized for broadly various purposes. Endeavors to unite this information across limits have given new comprehension into exactly how troublesome cross-limit data sharing is. Tracking down ways of uniting data and coordinate it for use in tackling squeezing public issues is quick turning into a focal point of consideration for computerized government professionals and scientists the same.

The absence of data is one of the primary issues for the vast majority legislative associations and high authorities, there is a need for the public authority associations and areas to share data for the advantages of the entire local area to accomplish better navigation and to convey a superior administration, without data sharing the coordinated administrations will be a wreck and the dynamic cycle will be based on presumptions more than realities. Egypt is still in the creating stage in term of the specialized framework (Bremer, 2013).

In reality the individual or little gatherings need a couple of measure of information and data to be divided among them to have the option to help and coordinate with one another likewise some data should be accessible for direction ,the gamble may be known and OK to tack the choice without enough data or to work and live alone in the people or little gatherings, yet on the public wise the gamble isn't OK at all it could prompt a fiasco to work in a secluded island or to tack choice without the enough data about it , additionally in the cutting edge government the administrations offered is definitely not a solitary association exertion it is an incorporated work between more than one association without the data stream between them the administrations conveyance well be pointless additionally the choice isn't the obligation of a specific association, a ton of legislative associations need to tack a few choices significantly affecting the public wise as service of wellbeing ,lodging or interior undertaking … and so on and the data required may be accessible just in some neighborhood unit or other association holding this information and don't have any desire to share it. Thus, need political readiness, public arrangement, and collaboration between not the legislative associations just yet with the confidential areas as well.

Is the data existing in any of the public authority association and Where? (In the event that the data is accessible where is in which association) in the wake of knowing whether accessible or not and where is data so How to get it? (Instructions to manage the associations which have the data we really want is with direct association, formal association, conidial information need a particular kind of conventions), this is obviously in addition to that a portion of the public authority association utilizing computerized capacity which make it simple to recover the data when required however some actually rely upon the old paper way what tack a ton of time particularly for old documented information.

Is the information required can be shared? It is a major issue particularly in the event that the association requesting the information is a similar level not a more significant position having the ability to arrange on this data (for example service from another service), and once more in the event that the association hold the data offer it Is the association requesting this data has the legitimate power to request this data, likewise the rehashed mentioned the contention in work lead to a Copy Required, in view of the absence of the data and combination some association might do similar occupation as the need might arise for a similar sort of data from a similar association which in some cases won't give the data again in light of the fact that it previously did.

Absence of Trust, numerous associations wouldn't share its own data on the organization in light of the need the confidence in the foundation and the organization security, as they consider the protection of the information likewise one of the central concern forestalling the mix is the Non Coordinated data sets, a ton of the association which rely upon the cutting edge innovation bases for correspondences and capacity can't speak with others effectively in view of the various sorts of data sets and various information structure IDSC (2017).

The work culture might cause the representatives oppose for transform; they would rather not impact their direction which they have certainty that it work with the most effective way, particularly the advanced age workers in the top administration on the off chance that they don't have the well they will impact it to the remainder of the association workers additionally the Association well, a portion of the association feel it's critical from the data they hold they feel that assuming that they surrender this data they will be pointless which make an opposition of some kind or another.

In certain associations the administration is the deterrent for the data sharing, the centralization way for the board put the power and the obligation in the administrator hand, which give them the position to say no and the opportunity to apprehensive on account of the obligation.

Service of Arranging, Observing and Regulatory Change (MPMAR) have explicit vision "Admittance to an authoritative equipped and fit for powerful preparation and administration of the assets of the state proceeding to execute public projects and activities and to offer brilliant public types of assistance esteems the fulfillment of the resident and the financial backer and the development, etc the premise of straightforwardness, uprightness and productivity and law and order and responsibility, to accomplish monetary turn of events and feasible civil rights and makes Egypt ripe land and an appealing worldwide, local and public ventures." Ministry of Planning (2017) mission and targets as Reasonable Advancement Technique (SDS) 2030 Service of Arranging, Observing and Regulatory Change, 2017.

MPMAR Great in arranging, where there is vital arranging division in the service, poor in association and issues in driving in spite of the fact that there is the choice of the President Board of Priests No. 856 for the year 2010. IDSC (2017) as a lawful cover On the trade and combination of public information and administrations between government organizations and doled out to it Service of State for regulatory turn of events (MSAD) that went to MPMAR and the issue was begun before 2010 up to this point (Fang, 2002).

Government manages everybody in the nation (senior, understudies, government authorities… and so forth) it manages them as people or collectively of business, government has a recent fad now daily's overall is to manage the resident as a client they need to convey them the best help in the most ideal way. So we really want to manage the resident as a client through the utilization of government to government (G2G).

Stakeholders Analysis

Drug store Robotization project chief said there is no vision of the state for mechanization, we find that the resident has a card for Supply, card for gas and ID, expected to be the one card for all tasks per resident. Every substance independently worked, and that sharing information and care about that thing for taking accomplishment for itself is troublesome. The spine string is the Common Status and, tragically, it isn't coordinated, and information are considered as public safety, has made just aid the political decision project after in 2011 and halted, information is obsolete.

General Overseer of the Branch of Data and Measurements Frameworks said that the substances don't assist all together with profiting from the defilement or that the administration isn't keen regarding the matter. The data set in certain substances is deficient or doesn't have the prepared to associate with G2G.

Know that connecting government organizations will save time, exertion and cash on the worker and resident and consequently the entire nation and will diminish the misuse of state assets and will help chiefs to take a precise choice).

Electronic installment project director said that one reason of G2G issues is the resistance of government organizations and there is no unmistakable political vision to carry out the venture and there isn't any sort of discipline from the non-execution of the State head's choice in such manner, there ought to be a commitment of all gatherings inside a predefined period and that there is a sort of severe discipline reported on account of non-execution (Chen & Aklikokou, 2020).

We might observe that the resistance is the consequence of irreconcilable situations and absence of trust in all that is electronic and not dole out skillful (Atia, 2011).

In spite of the issuance of a conventional choice in such manner however there is no wide vision and the public interest and there is no reasonable declaration to exploit it.

To embrace G2G, government substances need to engaged with computerization to connect them and crafted by the trading of data, assuming we think about the circumstance in exceptionally cheerful situation by the current framework and applications, as well as interfacing lines, yet it sadly some administration elements that are making question against the pounds and this isn't legitimate how to get government-material remuneration in getting data from other government hand.

The main places of Debasement is to take advantage of the obliviousness of the public authority in the state, it very well might be a resident have a particular solicitation goes to the mark of power and it tell him no , and goes to another substance shares with him yes.

To take on G2G it important to dole out the task under the administration of the republic and that there is no choices for the bodies and that the connection isn't discretionary however commitment, and he will be executed at all levels of the state.

Conceptual Model

The proposed conceptual model of G2G adoption as Figure 1

Figure 1: The Proposed Conceptual Model Of G2g Adoption.

Claims

Claim 1: E- government is the utilization of innovation to upgrade the admittance to and conveyance of government data and administrations to residents, business, government representatives and different organizations e-government is a huge variable in G2G reception. The sort is Free factor.

Claim 2: Efficiency Productivity characterized as substances answering public interest for better and more open Government, the expansion in effectiveness the expansion in G2G reception. The sort is Free factor.

Claim 3: Transparency is receptiveness to the public eye. It alludes to the sum, scope, quality, exactness and idealness of data which is open to applicable partners. Further developing straightforwardness lead to responsibility will hence prompt superior execution as well as it will make trust in state possession, so it is critical component in G2G reception. The sort is Autonomous variable.

Claim 4: Service quality is a proportion of how well a conveyed administration matches the residents' assumption, the expansion in help quality the expansion in G2G reception. The sort is Autonomous variable.

Research Questions

Major questions: MjRQ: How to take on government to government (G2G)?
Minor questions
MinRQ1: Is there any estimations e-States public worth?
MinRQ2: How to quantify substances efficiencies?
MinRQ3: How straightforward is the information gathering techniques utilized?
MinRQ4: What administration quality means for G2G reception?

Literature Review

Introduction

An e-government Model, The primary parts that can be recognized in e-government will be government, resident, worker and business. So the really normal connection in e-Government are G2C (Government to Resident), G2B (Government to Business), G2E (Government to Representative) and G2G (Government to Government) which is obviously shown Figure 2.

Figure 2: An E- Government Model.

The issue confronted legislatures around the world, how to change data and information. Improvement of data and correspondence advancements assists us with carrying out and upgrade e-Taxpayer driven organizations. There are various models in an e-government framework; the main one is G2G (Dar Al-Ifta, 2015).

Legislatures in numerous nations center its endeavors toward carried out e-government for of diminishing expenses, further developing administrations, saving time and expanding adequacy and proficiency in the public area (Alshehri & Drew, 2010).

The reason for e-government isn't just the transformation of conventional data into and making it reachable through the sites. In any case, it likewise calls for reexamining ways the public authority capabilities are done today to further develop cycles and coordination (Alshehri & Drew, 2010).

The proposed administrations in the G2G model are E-Secretariat, E-Police, E-Court, E-Court (Pathak & Kaur, 2014).

G2G Definition

The internet based non-business association between Government associations, offices, and specialists and other Government associations, divisions, and specialists through Data dividing across associations among government various associations and public associations to convey better administrations for the residents and to give the chiefs the data required.

G2G overview worldwide

Number of locales represents e-government potential. These praiseworthy locales endeavor to smooth out and customize the experience by recognizing clients and their motivation. They highlight tweaked passage focuses and benefits for government representatives, residents and organizations, and different offices and states. They integrate refined inquiry and search capabilities to assist users with rapidly finding the data and administration they need (DeBenedictis et al., 2002).

As indicated by (DeBenedictis et al., 2002). Consequently, we can close from the exploration speculation that the general way to deal with creating G2G is an arrangement of frameworks approach what separates into two capacities: a) organization — data combination for innovation the executive’s independent direction, and b) incorporation — coordinated admittance across various innovation data set frameworks Table 1.

Table 1
Sums Up Instances Of Sites At Various Degrees Of Government
Name and URL Level Participants Stage Comment
Economic Dev. Council of Collier County, Florida www.enaplesflorida.com Local (county) G2B Interact Designed to inform and promote; interactivity includes special premium access for member organizations
City of Colorado Springs www.springsgov.com Local (city) G2G, G2B, G2C Transact Comprehensive portal to city services and info; product of an intensive e-gov initiative
State of Alaska www.state.ak.us State G2B, G2C Interact Limited interactivity, very limited transactionality confined mostly to online job application; consists mostly of simple lists of links to state agencies
State of North Carolina www.ncgov.com State G2G, G2B, G2C Transact Customizable, comprehensive portal to state government services for all constituents
USGovernment www.firstgov.org National (federal) G2G, G2B, G2C Transact Ambitious initiative has disappointed, garnering visits from less than 0.3 percent of non-government Internet users in a recent month; most users bypass gateway to go directly to relevant agency (8)
Government of Singapore www.ecitizen.gov.sg National (City- State) G2G, G2B, G2C Transact Highly advanced, comprehensive services portal for one of the world's most technologically progressive city-states; citizen can complete nearly all government services online via a ubiquitous broadband network

G2G Give the States division's collaboration and correspondence online base on super data set of government to affect productivity and viability. It likewise incorporates inner trade of data.

Theories Defined

UTAUT Model

The UTAUT (Bound together Hypothesis of Acknowledgment and Utilization of Innovation) model for e-government reception in Saudi Arabia as displayed in Figure 3 (Al-Sobhi et al., 2011).

Figure 3: Utaut Model.

There is a huge connection between three builds (exertion expectance, trust of web and trust of go-between) and e-government reception conduct and these three develops having assumes major areas of strength for an in deciding e-government reception. Further, this investigation discovered that there is a critical connection between the working with conditions develop and utilization of e-taxpayer driven organizations, which obviously demonstrates that the additional working with conditions (delegates) Saudi e-government have the more hindrances that will be taken out, facilitating the resident's commitment with e-government because of a starter study, this study doesn't gauge the mediator factors in UTAUT (Al-Sobhi et al., 2011).

E-Government Services Quality Model

E-Taxpayer supported organizations Quality model has been laid out with data quality, framework quality and administration quality as key variables in light of the parts of online help quality discernment and disconnected help quality discernment, in view of IS (data framework) Achievement model and SERQUAL model (SERQUAL is basically in five aspects, physical assets, dependability, responsiveness, affirmation, and compassion to gauge different parts of the nature of administration. E-taxpayer supported organizations quality model as displayed in Figure 4.

The web-based help quality comprises of three factors, separately, data quality, framework quality and administration quality. For data quality, the accentuation is on the lucidity of the e-government data. The Web has turned into the principal wellspring of data.

For framework quality, it comprises of two factors: security and solidness. Security is a significant variable influencing the nature of e-taxpayer supported organizations. E-government framework should guarantee the security and privacy of clients' data.

For administration quality, this spotlights on two factors: intelligent administrations and "one-stop" administrations. The two factors altogether affect further developing internet based assistance quality. Intelligent e-taxpayer driven organization alludes to offer agreeable types of assistance for clients rapidly and proactively, tackle issues, answer questions, as well as the capacity to offer customized types of assistance, including three angles: further developing productivity, dynamic comprehension of client needs and offering customized types of assistance as indicated by various client necessities.

The internet-based taxpayer supported organizations quality is the most immediate component on open fulfillment of e-government. Disconnected taxpayer supported organization quality through its effect on impression of online administrations quality, in this manner by implication affects public fulfillment. Consequently, the public authority ought to zero in on further developing the e-government online assistance quality to further develop the public help fulfillment of e-taxpayer driven organizations; yet this doesn't imply that the public authority can overlook the nature of the customary taxpayer supported organizations. Great disconnected benefits affect working on open view of online help quality (Fan & Yang, 2015).

An Economic Model

"The model is relying upon innovation association climate (TOE) structure determined to distinguish different elements influence to G2Gdevelopment process”.

There are three develops, foundation, government CIO (Boss Data Official) and e-government advancement exercises to G2G reception level.

Foundation including the versatile organization inclusion, worldwide Web transfer speed, gets Web servers, and power creation. Government CIO is estimated not just by the presence of a CIO in various degrees of government yet additionally by the presence of regulations, guidelines and strategies which were proclaimed to command and distinguish the job of CIO unequivocally.

E-government advancement incorporates legitimate systems and instruments. The result unequivocally upheld for every one of the three speculations which demonstrates that foundation, government IT administration and e-government advancement exercises have impacts to the degree of G2G reception as follow.

H1: Framework is decidedly connected with G2G reception.
H2: Government CIO has a positive impact to the outcome of G2Gadoption.
H3: Government advancement exercises decidedly effects on the achievement pace of G2G reception

Conclusion

In the main model, the analyst tried a few factors, not every one of them, he rejected the directing variable. Hence it is problematic.

The subsequent model was keen on the factors of data quality, framework quality and administration quality albeit these are significant factors yet from my applied model the assistance quality is incorporated yet this autonomous variable not critical.

In any case, the third model tried the variable of e-government, where in my reasonable model e-government is a huge component. Thus, I rely upon it in the subsequent stage of my hypothetical structure.

Theoretical Framework and Research Design

Theoretical Framework

The proposed hypothetical system depends on the model of Anch, 2015 addressing factors influencing to G2G reception is displayed as in figure 4, where included free factor e-government advancement near factor in the calculated model, so I will rely upon it.

Figure 4: E-Government Services Quality Model.

The Dependent Variable: G2G adoption, a perplexing cycle requires the contribution of different associations, every one of them has an interesting construction, functionalities, culture, objectives information and business process. What's more, G2G reception incorporates both specialized and non-specialized viewpoints, of which different impacts from social and association variables might influence the result.

The Independent Variables

Infrastructure, a satisfactory foundation which incorporates data framework executed inside an organization as well as the protected advanced connect between offices is one of the significant assets required for creating G2G projects.

E- Government promotion, alludes to the level of government supporting for e-government drives which incorporates legitimate structures, (regulation, regulations, plans, approaches and techniques) and system (financing, supervise associations, result assessment).

Government CIO, the way that the central data officials obligations are not generally confined around specialized features yet are reached out to deal with additional confounded liabilities, for example, strategy arranging, spending plan the board, ICT speculation. The presence of strong boss data officials at all degrees of government is accepted to have the option to characterize rules and principles for coordinated effort and data sharing. Furthermore, a strong initiative could assist with building understanding, advance trust among taking part organizations and explain jobs and obligations during the undertaking system.

The moderating variable: Service quality is a proportion of how well a conveyed administration matches the residents' assumption, the expansion in help quality the expansion in G2G reception. The sort is Autonomous variable.

Research Questions

Major questions

MjRQ: How to take on government to government (G2G)?

Minor questions

MinRQ1: Is there any estimations e-States advancement esteem?
MinRQ2: What is the job of Government CIO?
MinRQ3: How straightforward is the information gathering techniques utilized?
MinRQ4: What is the suitable framework expected to G2G reception?

Hypothetical Statement

HΦ1: Framework is decidedly connected with G2G reception.
Ha1: Framework is decidedly connected with G2G reception.

HΦ2: Government CIO has a positive impact to the progress of G2Gadoption.
Ha2: Government CIO has a positive impact to the outcome of G2Gadoption.
HΦ3: E-government advancement exercises decidedly effects on the achievement pace of G2G reception.
Ha3: E-government advancement exercises decidedly effects on the achievement pace of G2G reception.
Ha4: Administration quality movement decidedly effects on the progress of G2G reception.

Research Methodology

Research Design

The paradigm is quantitative for a descriptive purpose due to contingent upon models not dispersed factors, and beginning the examination with distinct measurements, it is utilized to depict the primary elements to give a general feeling of the information being broke down utilizing the recurrence investigations. The second estep the connection examination will be utilized.

Gathering information from a regular habitat for factors as a field concentrate in a (no control) (no control) setting with no impedance (0% negligible).

Time skyline is a cross-sectional review where gathering information once.

Data Collection

The essential information will be gathered through utilizing a human intuitive wellspring of focus group which comprises of eight to ten individuals for the public authority authorities from addressing various sorts of the administrative levels (top administration, center administration and staff). Starting with utilizing unstructured meeting technique to guarantee about the factors lastly will involve the survey strategy for the public authority official by two unique ways.

•Hard copy version being collected personally
•Soft copy version sends by e-mail

Unstructured Interview

In the unstructured Meeting, I will present the subject of the conversation and permit respondents to being discussing their convictions concerns and perspectives to explore the accompanying issues.

• Check the best way to adopt government to government (G2G)
• Check the influence of e-Governments promotion on G2G adoption.
• Check the role of Government CIO on G2G adoption.
• Check the effect of service quality on G2G adoption.
• Check the appropriate infrastructure needed to G2G adoption

Questionnaire Development

After consummation of the center gathering through the unstructured meeting, considering the outcomes, I will produce survey inquiries to approve the factors (Saleh Kamel Center for Islamic Economy, 2011).

Sampling

The universe focuses on certain associations in the public authority particularly those have an involvement in data sharing cycle, the quantity of components for models:-

• Service of State for managerial turn of events (MSAD) All out worker ≈ 400.
• Service of Correspondence and data innovation (MCIT).
• An association to masseur the acknowledgment of the workers and the chiefs to the novel thought.

Obviously, the quantity of workers from the various levels will be different as the top administration numbers is excessively not exactly the center ones, but the populace was focusing on representatives in the administrative level more than the staff since they are in more need to the data than the low-level representative, Sadly, the quantity of respondents or subjects couldn't be established in data set.

The subject of exploration isn't basic, so non delegate testing required and not generalizable by any means.

Sampling method: Non-Likelihood Inspecting
Sampling Criteria: Critical Inspecting

The Accompanying Standards were Utilized for Choosing

• Top administration in the public authority
• Works in government for the beyond 15 years
• Mindful of the e-taxpayer driven organizations
• His/her work capability requires connection with one more association in government.

References

Al-Sobhi, F., Weerakkody, V., & El-Haddadeh, R. (2011). The relative importance of intermediaries in egovernment adoption: a study of saudi arabia. InElectronic Government: 10th IFIP WG 8.5 International Conference, EGOV 2011, Delft, The Netherlands, August 28–September 2, 2011. Proceedings 10, 62-74.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref

Alshehri, M., & Drew, S. (2010). Implementation of e-government: advantages and challenges.International Association for Scientific Knowledge (IASK), 79-86.

Indexed at, Google Scholar

Chen, L., & Aklikokou, A.K. (2020). Determinants of E-government adoption: testing the mediating effects of perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use.International Journal of Public Administration,43(10), 850-865.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref

Atia, M. (2011). Islamic approaches to development: a case study of zakat, sadaqa and qurd al hassan in contemporary egypt. In8th International Conference on Islamic Economics and Finance, Center for Islamic Economics and Finance, Qatar Faculty of Islamic Studies, Qatar Foundation.

Indexed at, Google Scholar

Bremer, J. (2013). Zakat and economic justice: Emerging international models and their relevance for Egypt. InThird Annual Conference on Arab Philantrophy and Civic Engagement, 51, 74.

Indexed at, Google Scholar

Dar Al-Ifta M. (2015). http://dar-alifta.org.eg/Foreign/ViewFatwa.aspx?ID=7741

DeBenedictis, A., Howell, W., Figueroa, R., & Boggs, R. (2002). E-government defined: an overview of the next big information technology challenge.Issues in Information Systems,3(1), 130-136.

Google Scholar

Fan, J., & Yang, W. (2015). Study on e-government services quality: The integration of online and offline services.Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management,8(3), 693-718.

Indexed at, Google Scholar, Cross Ref

Fang, Z. (2002). E-government in digital era: concept, practice, and development.International journal of the Computer, the Internet and management,10(2), 1-22.

Indexed at, Google Scholar

IDSC. (2017). http://www.eip.gov.eg/Documents/StudiesDetails.aspx?id=869  

Ministry of Planning. (2017). http://mpmar.gov.eg/

Pathak, M., & Kaur, G. (2014). Impact of e-governance on public sector services.International Journal of Emerging Research in Management &Technology,3(4), 100-103.

Google Scholar

Saleh Kamel Center for Islamic Economy. (2011). Retrieved 2015, from http://www.skcie.com/#

Received: 04-Aug-2023, Manuscript No. JMIDS-23-13904; Editor assigned: 07-Aug-2023, Pre QC No. JMIDS-23-13904(PQ); Reviewed: 21-Aug-2023, QC No. JMIDS-23-13904; Revised: 22-Aug-2023, Manuscript No. JMIDS-23-13904(R); Published: 29-Aug-2023

Get the App