Journal of Entrepreneurship Education (Print ISSN: 1098-8394; Online ISSN: 1528-2651)

Research Article: 2020 Vol: 23 Issue: 4

The Effect of Economic Literacy, Capital, Labor, and Marketing on Development of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)

Siti Nurjanah, Universitas Negeri Jakarta, Indonesia

Suparno, Universitas Negeri Jakarta, Indonesia

Kardoyo, Universitas Negeri Semarang, Indonesia

Disman, Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia, Indonesia

Citation Information: Nurjanah, S., Suparno., Kardoyo., & Disman. (2020). The effect of economic literacy, capital, labor, and marketing on development of small and medium enterprises (SMEs). Journal of Entrepreneurship Education, 23(4).

Abstract

Economic education with economic literacy and factors of production is a major study of the development of small and medium industries. Even capital as a factor of the company's production. This study aims to examine and prove the factors that influence the development of small and medium enterprises in the tourism business industry. Internal factors identified two main formers, namely economic literacy and marketing. External factors, namely capital and labor as factors of production. The model was compiled effectively and analyzed with a single multiple regression structure to determine the direct effect with the processed questionnaire survey results from 90 entrepreneurs as the owner of the company. Research data were analyzed using AMOS 25 and SPSS 20. The results showed that labor and marketing made the main contribution, followed by economic and capital literacy. Simultaneously influential by 86% and significant. it breaks capital and economic literacy as the main thing in small and medium businesses. The implication of the results of this study is the importance of identifying and developing labor, marketing, capital, and economic literacy in Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs).

Keywords

Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs), Entrepreneurship Development, Economic Literacy, Capital, Labor, Marketing.

Introduction

Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) play a strategic power and have an important position, not only in terms of employment and public welfare but also to stabilize the problem of social inequality. Products produced by small businesses are generally also based on the needs of the wider community and have comparative advantages. Also, small businesses that have factors of production are not dependent on foreign exchange, able to withstand the crisis than large businesses. Thus, the development of small businesses is important for deeper review.

Existing small and medium businesses have created employment for around 116 million local workers. The Central Statistics Agency noted that the number of micro and small businesses in Indonesia continues to grow each year. Based on data from 2013 to 2015 the number of micro and small businesses reached 10 million units (Statistics, 2018). The increase in small and medium businesses occurs due to the ability to produce superior products with professional management (Prasanna et al., 2019); (Vandenberg et al., 2016); (Hutahayan, 2019).

The role of small industries in society has become a very important part of the Indonesian economy (Kurniawan & Managi, 2018). Almost all existing industrial activities involve the largest share in people's economic activities. Availability of industrial development factors such as capital, raw materials, transportation, location, and marketing. It is important to study economic literacy for entrepreneurs to provide a model for increasing literacy capabilities in the management and optimization of resources (Suparno & Saptono, 2018); (Jolaee et al., 2014); (Pandey & Gupta, 2018) including economic learning experience in entrepreneurial creativity (Wibowo et al., 2018).

Various obstacles often encountered in small businesses are the low quality of labor. Manpower plays an important role in encouraging business development. The thing that must be possessed by a worker is skill because it is a capital that must be possessed to become a productive workforce. Measuring the level of productivity can be known from the length of time the workforce has worked and experience. For example, a worker who works for five years will be more experienced than one who works for two years.

Small and Medium Enterprises focus on excellence and potential with innovation and good business management towards entrepreneurial independence. The tourism industry is very interesting to be studied and developed in the industrial era 4.0 and the development of this 21st-century industry due to various large industrial businesses closing businesses. The tourism industry is attached to regional excellence and potential, so the ability to survive and develop needs to be examined.

Development of Small and Medium Enterprises

Small and medium-sized businesses are businesses that are often carried out independently (self-employment), do not require high skills, weak business or academic background, and lack insight into developments outside. Business development can be divided into 5 stages, namely, the stage conceptual, start-up, stabilization, growth (growth stage), and maturity. This discussion will discuss business development from the stage conceptual, namely (Soeharto Prawirokusumo, 2007):

1. Get to know potential opportunities.

2. Analyze opportunities.

3. Organizing resources.

4. The step of mobilizing resources and accepting risk as a final step before going to the stage startup.

Judi states that small business success is measured by business survival, numbers of employees, and income (Sakur, 2011). Meanwhile, according to Madura, business development can be measured through business performance with indicators of return and risk from investment to the business (Jeff, 2006). According to Apilido, the performance of small and medium businesses in meeting their obligations can be measured (Sakur, 2011):

5. Business continuity (survival business).

6. Employee growth.

7. Credit quality.

8. Credit growth.

9. Use of credit.

10. Monitoring from banks.

Shanmugam & Bhaduri (2007) states that the development of small businesses can be seen through production growth, sales growth, revenue growth and profit growth (Shanmugam and Bhaduri, 2007) reflected by business performance, namely the level of achievement of results and the level of achievement of organizational goals (Kristiningsih, 2014) with sales growth (sales growth), employment growth (employment growth), income growth (income growth)and growth in market share(market share growth) as a measurement of the development of the most important small companies (Khoiruddin & Aslichah, 2017).

The business development in this research is an increase in the ability of the company both in terms of quality of work and in terms of the quantity of business carried out with new and directed patterned activities and is the result of a continuous process. Business development can be measured through production growth and sales growth. The factors that influence business development include venture capital, labor, and marketing.

Economic Literation

Economic science studies the efforts of humans both individually and in the community to make choices about the use of limited resources to meet the needs for goods and services (Basiago, 1998). Economic literacy is the ability to read to determine the appropriate use of available resources will have an impact on intelligence in managing the economy and finance through priority scale in transactions and the ability to analyze economic conditions.

Metiri states that economic literacy as the ability to identify economic problems, alternatives, costs, and benefits; analyze the incentives at work in economic situations; examine the consequences of changes in economic conditions and public policies; collect and organize economic evidence; and weigh costs against benefits (Kharizmi, 2015), while Yasmin et al. (2014) states that economic literacy is the understanding and knowledge of basic economic theories, concepts and their applications (Ai Nur Solihat, 2018). According to Pandey & Bhattacharya (2012), economic literacy is the ability to use economic concepts to make decisions about income, savings, expenditure and allocate money in improving welfare (Nuraeni, 2015). Economic literacy is a means to an end, it's just that in reality, not everyone has high economic literacy, thus narrowing the chances of prosperity (Sina, 2017) The Survey conducted by the Minnesota Center for Survey Research at the University of Minnesota shows a good understanding of the principle-economic principles especially microeconomic issues, such as market operations and sources of personal income) and have the greatest direct impact on their daily lives, specifically related to microeconomic issues (Neti Budiwati, 2014; Nuraeni, 2015).

Economic literacy according to The National Center on Education and the Economy with 20 indicators measuring the level of community economic literacy (Iqomudin, 2017). In this study economic literacy for small and medium industry entrepreneurs is measured by being able to analyze changes in demand for goods, being able to manage the role of entrepreneurs, being able to analyze changes in supply and demand, being able to analyze the impact of government policies on pricing, being able to analyze the impact of changes in demand and supply on goods prices, able to explain the use of limited resources, able to analyze the costs and benefits of economic transactions, able to analyze the impact of inflation, able to analyze industrial development.

Capital

Capital is all goods that exist in the household of a company in its productivity function to form income (Bambang, 2010). The term capital as a factor of production which refers to the facilities and infrastructure produced to be used as input in the production process. To buy capital goods, capital is needed in the sense of funds or money (Muhammad, 2006). Capital is all forms of wealth that can be used directly or indirectly in production to increase output (Tulus Tambunan, 2009; 2019). Based on the three definitions above, it can be synthesized that capital is everything that is owned by the company in the form of money or objects needed to support the process of producing goods or services.

Capital is something that is used to carry out company operations (Kasmir, 2010). Capital can be interpreted as anything made by humans that are used in the production process (Sugiarto, 2006). Capital can be in the form of buildings, machinery, and other equipment, or the form of a sum of money or funds (Bambang, 2010). Based on the three definitions above, it can be synthesized that capital is everything in the form of goods and wealth owned by the company to support production activities.

Capital is needed from the time the company was started and used to buy various inputs, including land as the location of the company. This business capital can be obtained from business partnerships that are established by small industries with other parties. The other party can be a government agency, a designated bank or a non-bank financing source. The implication of increased capital is the expansion of small industrial business networks, and this factor also indicates that an industry has developed.

Based on expert studies above, capital is one of the factors driving the variable in business development. Capital has a positive influence on business development. The greater or increased capital owned, the business will increase and vice versa if the capital owned is small or decreases, the business will decrease.

Labor

Labor is one component of production that has a significant role in the continuity of industry (Gregory, 2009). Workers can also be interpreted as individuals who offer the skills and abilities to produce goods or services so that companies can benefit. And for that individuals will get a salary or wage by the skills they have (Murti & John, 2014). Every person who works for a wage or reward and is in an employment relationship is called a workforce (Mulyadi, 2014). Based on the three definitions above, it can be synthesized that labor is an individual with the ability and skills to produce goods or services.

Manpower is a human resource that has the potential, ability, appropriate, efficient, personal in certain categories to work and participate in the development so that it is effective for himself and society as a whole (Oemar, 2005). According to Joesron, the quality of labor is the potential, strength, or ability that exists in human beings that determines human attitudes and qualities to be able to excel and keep the organization alive and running. Kasanudin measured the quality of the workforce based on productivity, attitude and behavior, communication, and relationship (Mega & Widiya, 2017).

Labor is one of the factors driving the variable business development. Labor has a positive influence on business development. The quality of labor will affect the product produced. The better the quality of the workforce, the more productive the performance will be. Business performance and increased production will affect the business development.

Marketing

William J. Stanton states that marketing is an overall system of business activities aimed at planning, pricing, promoting and distributing goods and services that satisfy the needs of both existing and potential buyers (Basu, 2007). Marketing is a social and managerial process by creating, offering, and exchanging products of value with others (Philip & Armstrong, 2007). The American Marketing Association says that marketing is the result of work performance from business activities related to the flow of goods and services from producers to consumers (Nur, 2010). Marketing is an activity to promote and distribute goods and services to groups of buyers. The purpose of industry is to produce goods for sale and for that marketing has an important role.

Entrepreneurial characteristics, access to capital and marketing strategies are closely related to business development. The success or failure of the marketing system is usually seen from the marketing of the product itself, competitive prices, varied and innovative promotions and places that are easily accessible to buyers (Purwanti, 2012).

Tull and Kahle state that the marketing is important to help improve the competitiveness of companies in facing the era of globalization and liberalization. Marketing is a fundamental tool that is planned to achieve company goals by developing a sustainable competitive advantage. So, marketing can help managers or company owners in carrying out tactics and other activities to improve company goals (Fandy, 2005). The success of a business is determined by the results of its marketing if the quality of the product is good and the quality of the consumer will not hesitate to order to the entrepreneur, because the price and quality are equal so that it will not disappoint consumers (Philip Kotler and G. Armstrong, 2006).

Based on the explanation above, it can be concluded that marketing is one of the driving factors of business development variables. Marketing has a positive influence on business development. A good marketing strategy will affect the number of products sold. The better the marketing strategy, the more products are sold. Increased sales volume will affect the business development. Based on the above study the following research hypotheses are formulated (Figure 1):

Figure 1 Unstandardized Estimate Multiple Regression

1. H1: There is a positive influence between economic literacy (ECL) on business development (ETD).

2. H2: There is a positive influence between capital (CAP) on business development (ETD).

3. H3: There is a positive influence between labor work (LAB) on business development (ETD).

4. H4: There is a positive influence between marketing (MAR) on business development (ETD).

Methodology

This research is quantitative by using a survey of small and medium businesses shopping tourism as data analysis. The population in this study were 90 small and medium entrepreneurs in the shopping tourism industry in the city of Depok, Indonesia, All were examined as samples. This study uses the Structural Model Single Equation analyzed with multiple regression analysis. with study analysis explain the relationship between multiple independent variable (IV) and one dependent variable (DV), Predict DV values based on known IV values, Explain the effect of each IV on DV (Tabachnick & Fidell, 2013) and to find structural relationships and provide explanations for seemingly complex multivariate relationships, such as is done in path analysis, (Ho, 2014: 293). Sample size: a minimum of 20 observations for each variable independent (Ho, 2014), or N ≥ 50+8m or N ≥ 104+m; m=number of IV (Tabachnick & Fidell, 2013).

The validity and reliability test of the items and the requirements for testing the hypothesis is to test the normal estimates of error, the linear test, and the significance of the regression coefficient and correlation - normality regression test using ANOVA. The formula used for the validity of the product is the Pearson test and the reliability test with Cronbach Alpha. Data were analyzed by Structural Model Single Equation analyzed with multiple regression analysis to analyze the relationship between variables on endogenous variables, data processed with AMOS 25 and SPSS 20.00.

Results and Discussion

The validity and reliability test of the items and the requirements for testing the hypothesis is to test the normal estimates of error, the linear test, and the significance of the regression coefficient and correlation - normality regression test using ANOVA. The formula used for the validity of the product is the Pearson test and the reliability test with Cronbach Alpha. Data were analyzed by Structural Model Single Equation analyzed with multiple regression analysis to analyze the relationship between variables on endogenous variables, data processed with AMOS 25 and SPSS 20.00.

The following Table 1 is a questionnaire developed and tested for SMEs.

Table 1 Item Measurement of Research Variables
Variable and Item measurement Validitas-Corrected Item-Total Correlation Reliability Cronbach's Alpha
1. ETD    
ETD1 Increased revenue in the last tree years 0.701 0.951
ETD2 Increased production capacity 0.700
ETD4 Production is able to meet consumer demand with supplies 0.666
ETD6 Accountable production report 0.708
ETD7 Able to achieve the target number and quality of production 0.673
ETD8 Increased sales volume 0.632
ETD10 Having innovation in new production 0.728
ETD11 Increase customers with good loyalty 0.637
ETD13 Having after sales service for customer satisfaction 0.695
ETD14 Add new business units 0.613
ETD15 Able to achieve annual sales targets 0.618
2. ECL    
ECL1 Being able to analyze changes in demand for goods 0.631 0.859
ECL3 Able to manage the role of entrepreneur 0.631
ECL4 Able to analyze changes in supply and demand 0.553
ECL5 Being able to analyze the impact of government policies 0.537
ECL6 Being able to analyze the impact of changes in demand and supply 0.586
ECL7 Able to explain the use of limited resources 0.617
ECL11 Able to analyze the costs and benefits of economic transactions 0.584
ECL13 Being able to analyze the impact of inflation 0.584
ECL14 Able to analyze industrial development 0.537
3. CAP    
CAP1 My venture capital is from private capital 0.829 0.93
CAP2 Access to get loans from banks 0.77
CAP3 Availability of subsidies from local governments 0.741
CAP4 Ease of getting capital in the form of money and goods 0.737
CAP5 Low or affordable interest 0.773
CAP7 Capital ability to raw materials 0.771
CAP8 Good and regular accounting reports 0.719
CAP9 Use of capital to increase equipment 0.733
4. LAB    
LAB1 Manpower needed special skills 0.57 0.863
LAB2 Manpower is not required for high education 0.641
LAB3 Labor costs are in accordance with the Provincial Minimum Wage 0.74
LAB4 The workforce is able to manage production 0.677
LAB5 Productivity workforce 0.542
LAB6 There is an increase in the skills of the workforce 0.671
LAB7 Control of the workforce 0.596
5. MRK    
MRK5 The average consumer is a distributor 0.59 0.845
MRK6 The majority of consumers are from organizational institutions 0.657
MRK7 Receive orders from consumers who are outside the region 0.659
MRK8 Marketing of regional business results 0.618
MRK9 Market your business online through e-commerce 0.659
MRK10 Marketing reaches all regions 0.59

Multiple Regression Analysis is performed to predict the effect between variables using AMOS 21, Unstandardized: Y=b0+b1X1+b2X2+…+bkXk+e. Different units of measurement, bk predict the value of Y if the value of Xk is known. Standardized: Y= β1X12X2+…+βkXk+e. Units of measurement are equated in standardized numbers (z score, average = 0 and standard deviation=1), βk (beta) measure the magnitude of each effect Xk to Y. the following data are obtained (Figure 2):

Figure 2 Standardized Estimate Multiple Regression

From standardized estimate, coefficient values can be seen in the table above so that the linear regression equation can be obtained as follows:

Ŷ=0.13X1+0.19X2+0.49X3+0.28X4+0.14e ; R2=0.86

That is, at 86% the variation that occurs in Y can explained together by X1, X2, X3 and X4. The remaining 14% is a variation in Y that is explained by other variables that are not researched (Figure 2).

Next measurement Effect Size (ES): image. ES=0.86-4/(90-1)=0.81.“Effect sizes criteria are small=0.1, medium=0.25, and large=0.4” (Schumacker & Lomax, 2016).

ES=0.41. Associated, fully with X1, X2, X3 and X4 are able to explain strongly the variations that occur in the Y variable. Based on the further t and F tests, partially and simultaneously there is a significant economic influence literacy, capital, labor, marketing, business development with entrepreneurship as follows (Table 2):

Table 2 Output Multiple Regression Coefficients
Model Dependent Var (Constan) Independent Varible F R Square
ECL CAP LAB MAR
Coeficient 5.086 0.126 0.185 0.493 0.281 129.106 0.859
SE 2.888 0.240 0.140 0.179 0.110    
t-test 1.761 2.947 2.253 5.745 4.823    
sig 0.082 0.004 0.027 0.000 0.000    

The magnitude of the coefficient the influence between variables that labor (0.493), marketing (0.281), capital (0.185) and economic literacy (0.126). This new finding is a study of entrepreneurial development in the tourism industry that labor and marketing is an important aspect for developing small and medium businesses. This study found that all variables have a significant influence including aspects of capital and economic literacy in the Small and Medium Enterprises development.

Conclusion

This research studies the factors that influence the development of small and medium entrepreneurs in the shopping tourism industry. A total of 90 entrepreneurs in the shopping tourism industry were involved, taking data with questionnaires only to the industry owner as a business controller. Based on the results of research on factors affecting business development in Shopping Tourism, the higher the level of economic literacy, capital, labor, and marketing, the better the business development. The level of capital, labor, and marketing must be increased to improve business development which results in increased profits (profits) of small and medium entrepreneurs who are in the Tourism Shopping. the total effect of all variables is 86% and significant based on the study is able to explain and answer the research problems proposed, 14% is influenced by other variables.

Based on the results of the questionnaire, to develop business in SMEs the largest dimension component in the aspect of increasing production contributed 50.8%, while the increase in sales volume was 49.2%. Economic literacy factors on the ability to analyze changes in supply and demand as well as their impact on the price of goods, analyzing the development of the industry contributes the largest 58%. Capital how to get capital, ease of getting capital, availability of capital, and management in using the biggest capital in the indicator of how to get capital is 34.1%. Labor with aspects of ease of obtaining workforce, labor requirements, wages, labor, manpower training, labor inspection, and labor management. The labor force is most influenced by the indicator of ease of obtaining labor, which is 14.45%. Marketing variables with ease of marketing the results of production, consumer purchasing power, consumer status, marketing area, strategies to determine marketing locations, and marketing distribution of marketing area indicators contributed 16.99%.

Research on the development of small and medium businesses with multi-predictor variables with the results reinforces the findings and studies of several researchers and previous theories. Hartono & Deny (2014) in Factors affecting the development of small and medium businesses, the results of the study showed that the problems with the cost of raw materials, labor costs and promotion costs, as well as in capital in developing small and medium businesses. Therefore, the business development strategy is more focused on fulfilling raw materials, marketing, production, and capital. Mega & Widiya (2017) in the factors that influence the development of Small Business in the Manufacturing Industry Sector, financial institutions and centers can support other factors, so that the processing industry can develop rapidly. Khoiruddin & Aslichah (2017) in the Analysis of Factors Influencing the Development of Micro and Small and Medium Enterprises including the fact that capital facilities have a significant contribution to the business development of the food and beverage production sector.

This research is still limited to entrepreneurs in shopping tourism with economic literacy, capital, labor, and marketing factors. The next researcher can examine on a broader scale in the tourism industry and aspects that influence its development such as education and training, government policy, innovation power, digital literacy, e-commerce and other aspects that have not been studied.

References

Ai Nur Solihat, S.A. (2018). Effect of economic literacy on consumptive behavior of students in the department of economic education at Siliwangi University. Journal of Economic Education and Economics Studies, 2, 141-152.

Bambang, R. (2010). Fundamentals of corporate spending. Yogyakarta: BPFE.

Basiago, A.D. (1998). Economic, social, and environmental sustainability in development theory and urban planning practice. Environmentalist, 19(2), 145–161.

Basu, S. (2007). Introduction to modern business, introduction to modern corporate economics. Jakarta: Liberty.

Budiwati, N. (2014). Dissertation: Analysis of economic literacy and consumer behavior. Bandung: Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia.

Fandy, T. (2005). Marketing strategy. 2nd edition, Yogyakarta: Andi Offset.

Gregory, M. (2009). Macroeconomics. Jakarta: Erlangga.

Hartono., & Deny, D.H. (2014). Factors that influence the development of SMEs in Surakarta. Journal of Business and Management, 14, 15-30.

Ho, R. (2014). Handbook of Univariate and multivariate data analysis

with IBM SPSS. NW: Chapman & Hall/CRC.

Hutahayan, B. (2019). Factors affecting the performance of Indonesian special food SMEs in entrepreneurial orientation in East Java. Asia Pacific Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, 13(2), 231-246.

Iqomudin, M.A. (2017). The influence of economic literacy, economic education in the family and the socio-economic background of parents against consumption decision making in IPS education students of the state Islamic university of Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang.

Jeff, M. (2006). Introduction to business. 1st edition, Jakarta: Salemba Empat.

Jolaee, A., Nor, K.M., Khani, N., & Yusoff, R.M. (2014). Factors affecting knowledge sharing intention among academic staff. International Journal of Educational Management, 28(4), 413-431.

Kharizmi, M. (2015). Difficulties of elementary school students in improving literacy skills. Journal of Basic Education, 2(2), 11-21.

Khoiruddin., & Aslichah. (2017). Analysis of factors affecting the development of micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) in Jombang Regency. Journal of the Trident LP2M, 5(1), 456-466.

Kristiningsih. (2014). Analysis of factors affecting the development of small and medium enterprises (Case study of SMEs in the Surabaya Region. The 7th NCFB Doctoral Collobium 2014 Faculty of Business and Postgraduate Wijaya Kusuma University Surabaya.

Kurniawan, R., & Managi, S. (2018). Bulletin of Indonesian economic studies economic growth and sustainable development in Indonesia, An Assessment Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 54(3), 1-31.

Mega, M., & Widiya. (2017) Factors influencing the development of small business in the manufacturing industry sector in malang city. Jibeka, 11(2), 73-79.

Muhammad, S. (2006) Sharia bank: From theory to practice. Jakarta: Gema Insani Press.

Mulyadi. (2014). Human resource economics in development perspective. Jakarta: PT Raja Grafindo Persada,

Murti, S., & John, S. (2014). Introduction to business fundamentals of economy company. Yogyakarta: Liberty.

Nur, M.R. (2010). Marketing basicsBandung: Alfabeta,

Nuraeni. (2015). The effect of economic literacy, peer groups, and self-control on impulsive buying behavior for fashion products on the students of the economics faculty of Yogyakarta state university. Ekp, 13(3), 1576-1580.

Oemar, H. (2005). Human resource development (management of employment training integrated approach). Jakarta: Earth Literacy.

Pandey, A., & Gupta, R. (2018). Entrepreneur's performance and financial literacy-a critical review. International Journal of Management Studies, 5(S3).

Pandey, C., & Bhattacharya. (2012). Economic literacy of senior secondary school teachers: a field study. Journal of the All India Association for Educational Research, 24(1).

Philip, K., & Armstrong, G. (2007). Marketing principles. Jakarta: Erlangga.

Prasanna, R.P.I.R., Jayasundara, J.M.S.B., Gamage, S.K.N., Ekanayake, E.M.S., Rajapakshe, P.S.K., & Abeyrathne, G.A.K.N.J. (2019). Sustainability of SMEs in the competition: A systemic review on technological challenges and SME performance. Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market, and Complexity, 5(4), 1-18.

Purwanti, E. (2012). Effect of entrepreneurial characteristics, business capital, marketing strategies on the development of SMEs in the Village of Dayaan and Kalilondo Salatiga. Online Journal, 5(9).

Sakur. (2011). Study of factors supporting the development of micro and small and medium enterprises: Case study in the city of Surakarta. ISSN Public Spirit, 7, 85-110.

Schumacker, R.E., & Richard, G.L. (2016). A beginner’s guide to SEM.

Fourth edition, New York: Routledge

Shanmugam., & Bhaduri. (2007). Size, age. and Firm Growth in the Indian Manufacturing Sector. Applied Economics Letters, 607-613.

Sina, P.G. (2017). Analysis of economic literacy, Peter Garlans Sina Sin. 135-143.

Statistics. (2018). August 2018: Open Unemployment Rate of 5.34 percent. Retrieved November 10, 2018, from the Central Statistics Agency website. Retrieved from www.bps.go.id

Sugiarto. (2006). Microeconomics: A comprehensive study. Jakarta: Gramedia.

Suparno., & Saptono., A. (2018). Entrepreneurship education and its influence on financial literacy and entrepreneurship skills in college. Journal of Entrepreneurship Education, 21(4), 1-11.

Tabachnick, B.G., & Fidell, L.S. (2013). Using multivariate statistics. Sixth Edition. Boston: Pearson Education, Inc.

Tambunan. (2009). The development of small scale industries in Indonesia. Jakarta: Salemba Empat.

Tambunan. (2019). The impact of the economic crisis on micro, small, and medium enterprises and their crisis mitigation measures in Southeast Asia with reference to Indonesia. Asia and the Pacific Policy Studies, 6(1), 19-39.

Vandenberg, P., Chantapacdepong, P., & Yoshino, N. (2016). SMEs in developing asia: New approaches to overcoming market failures. In the Asian Development Bank Institute.

Wibowo, A., Saptono, A., & Suparno. (2018). Does the teacher's creativity impact vocational students' entrepreneurial intentions? Journal of Entrepreneurship Education, 21(3).

Yasmin, F., Kouser, R., Hassan, I., & Ahmad, W. (2014). Determinants of economic literacy at the university level: A case of Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of Commerce and Social Sciences (PJCSS), 8(3), 914-924.